Many websites have had polls on this, and I have found the best lists only 80 to 90% accurate. Here's mine, and bear in mind, some of these are uncommon, and one person's experience doesn't make a sure case. Interestingly all of most people's top 10 are Amphilophines from Centrtal America and Hispaniola (they're Crazy Good!), except the Green Terror, Aequidens rivulatus.
The Top 3 are easy: Beani, Umbee, Haitian Black Nasty. 4 and 5 are usually Dovii and Flowerhorn.
6. Islantum
7. Red Festae
8. Red Texas
9. Trimac
10. Motaguense
Questionable: Green Terror,Jaquar, Midas or Red Devil (they are different races of A. labiatus), Grammoides (the Mini Dovii)
Past Stupid Picks: Severum, Oscar, Buttikoferi
Submit Your List!